Every expensive landlord story starts the same way: a tenant who looked fine at move-in and stopped paying by month three. Screening doesn't prevent every bad tenancy — nothing does — but it filters out the predictable ones. The tenants who can't afford the rent, who have evicted before, or who left their last landlord with damage are usually visible in the paperwork before you hand over the keys, if you know where to look and you're willing to say no to a vacant unit for one more week.
The other half of screening is legal. The Fair Housing Act and state laws draw hard lines around what you can ask and what you can use to decide, and the penalties for crossing them are worse than a month of vacancy. This page covers both halves: a practical screening standard, and the rules that keep it lawful.
Step one: write your criteria before you meet anyone
Write your rental criteria down before the first application arrives — and apply the same list to every applicant. That single habit is your best defense against a discrimination claim, because a written standard you can show is the difference between "I apply these rules to everyone" and "I decide case by case." A typical written standard covers four things:
- Income: gross monthly income of 2.5 to 3 times the rent, verified with pay stubs or bank statements.
- Credit: a minimum score, plus a look at the pattern — collections, recent late payments, and rental-related debts matter more than the number alone.
- Rental history: no evictions in the past three to five years, no unpaid balance owed to a prior landlord, and a reference from the most recent landlord.
- Background: a criminal history check that follows your state's rules — several states restrict what you can consider, and blanket bans on any criminal record are risky under federal guidance.
Put the criteria in the listing itself. Applicants who don't meet them self-select out, you get fewer unqualified applications, and everyone sees the same bar before they apply. Keep a copy of the criteria with each application file, with a note on which criteria each applicant met or failed — that record is what you show if anyone ever asks why you chose one applicant over another.
The income test, with numbers
The 3-times-rent rule is the most common standard: gross monthly income at least three times the rent. For a $2,000-a-month unit, that's $6,000 a month, or $72,000 a year. The 2.5-times standard — $5,000 a month, $60,000 a year for the same unit — is common in higher-rent markets where 3x would exclude most working tenants. Pick one, write it down, and use it consistently; switching between 2.5x for one applicant and 3x for another is exactly how a fair-housing problem starts.
Verify income; don't take an applicant's word for it. Two recent pay stubs and a bank statement showing the deposits will confirm most employment income. For self-employed applicants, ask for the last two months of bank statements and the most recent tax return. Count stable income only — a one-time bonus or a side job that started last month doesn't count the same way as a salary. And count the household's combined income for everyone who will be on the lease; a two-earner household that clears 3x together is a different risk than a single earner who doesn't.
The rule that protects you most: the same standard for everyone, in writing, before you see a single application. Discrimination cases rarely turn on what a landlord intended — they turn on whether the landlord can show a consistent, documented reason for the decision. Written criteria, applied uniformly, are that proof.
Credit and rental history: what actually predicts problems
Pull a credit report with the applicant's written permission — you need it, and the screening service will require it. Look past the score itself. A 640 score with one old medical collection and five years of on-time rent is a better tenant than a 700 score with a recent eviction judgment and three maxed-out cards. The items that predict rental trouble most reliably:
| What you see | What it usually means |
|---|---|
| Eviction judgment or unlawful detainer filing | Highest-risk signal; verify it wasn't dismissed or settled |
| Unpaid balance to a prior landlord | Direct evidence of a past tenancy ending in debt |
| Recent collections (last 12 months) | Current financial stress, not an old mistake |
| Multiple late payments in the last year | A pattern of paying obligations late |
| Old medical collection, otherwise clean | Weak signal on its own; weigh it lightly |
Always call the previous landlord — not the current one, who has an incentive to give a good reference to get the tenant out, but the one before that. Ask three questions: Did they pay on time? Did they give proper notice? Would you rent to them again? A hesitant answer to the third question tells you more than a credit score will. And verify the landlord is real: a "landlord reference" with a mobile number and no property records is sometimes the applicant's friend.
What you cannot ask or use
Federal Fair Housing law prohibits discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex (including gender identity and sexual orientation), national origin, familial status and disability. Many states and cities add more: source of income (including housing vouchers), age, marital status, and criminal history protections among them. In practice this means:
- Don't ask about family plans or children beyond the number of occupants for occupancy limits. "Are you planning to have kids?" is not a screening question.
- Don't treat voucher income differently if your state or city protects source of income — and many now do. Check before you write "no Section 8" in a listing.
- Don't use a blanket criminal-history ban. Federal guidance says a blanket ban on anyone with a criminal record has a discriminatory effect; consider the nature of the offense, how long ago it was, and whether it relates to tenancy safety. Several states now restrict criminal-history screening outright.
- Don't ask about disability or medical conditions. You may ask whether the applicant needs a reasonable accommodation, and you must consider accommodation requests — a ramp, a service animal in a no-pets building — on their merits.
- Don't steer. Showing different units, quoting different terms, or discouraging an applicant from applying because of who they are is discrimination even if no application is ever filed.
Application fees are regulated too: several states cap them (New York caps the fee at $20, for example) and many require you to give the applicant a copy of the report or a receipt. Check your state's cap before charging, and never charge a fee you can't justify.
State and local rules vary widely and change often — source-of-income protection, criminal-history limits and fee caps differ by jurisdiction. This page is general information; check your state and city rules before you finalize your criteria.
Saying no: the adverse action notice
If you reject an applicant based on information in a consumer report — a credit report, an eviction history, a background check — federal law (the Fair Credit Reporting Act) requires you to send an adverse action notice. It must name the consumer reporting agency that provided the report, state that the agency didn't make the decision, and tell the applicant they can get a free copy of the report within 60 days and dispute anything wrong in it. Send it in writing, keep a copy, and keep it with the application file.
If you reject for a reason unrelated to a report — income below your written standard, for example — no adverse action notice is required, but send a brief written rejection anyway, citing the criterion that wasn't met. Short, factual and consistent: "Your application was not approved because your verified gross monthly income of $4,200 does not meet our written requirement of 3x the $2,000 monthly rent ($6,000)." That letter is both courteous and, if it ever matters, the record of a legitimate, documented reason. Never give a verbal rejection with no paper trail, and never give a reason you didn't actually apply — like telling an applicant "we went with someone else" when the real reason was a credit item you never disclosed.
Keep every application, report, note and rejection letter for at least three years. A discrimination complaint can arrive long after the unit is rented, and by then your memory of which applicant failed which criterion will be gone. The file is your memory.
Track it in one spreadsheet
The Rental Property Tracker logs rent and expenses per property, maps every expense to its Schedule E line, and prints a CPA-ready year-end summary. Start with the free one-sheet rent ledger, or get the full tracker.
Get the Tracker — $29 Free Rent Ledger (Excel)
One-time price · Excel & Google Sheets · Bundle with Airbnb module available for $49.
FAQ
What credit score should I require?
There is no universal minimum, and the score alone is a weak filter — many landlords use 600–650 as a floor and weigh the pattern behind the number more heavily. What matters is that the number is written in your criteria and applied to every applicant, not adjusted per person.
Can I charge an application fee?
Yes in most states, but the amount is capped in several — New York caps it at $20, and other states set their own limits or require you to provide the report copy. Check your state's cap, charge only your actual screening cost, and give a receipt.
Can I reject an applicant with an eviction on their record?
Generally yes, if eviction history is in your written criteria and you apply it consistently — but verify the record first. Filings that were dismissed, settled, or filed in error still appear on some reports, and rejecting on a wrong record creates liability. Confirm the outcome before you decide.
Do I have to accept housing vouchers?
It depends on your state and city. Federal law doesn't require it, but a growing number of states and cities prohibit source-of-income discrimination, which includes vouchers. If your jurisdiction protects it, you must treat voucher income like any other verifiable income — and count the voucher's rent portion in the income test.