landlord.tabpic.com

Security Deposit Deductions: What Landlords Can Legally Withhold

The deposit isn't a cleaning budget. Here's what you can withhold, what counts as normal wear, and how to document it so it holds up.

The tenant moved out, the keys are back, and the place needs work. The deposit is sitting in your account — and the question is how much of it you can keep. This is the single most disputed part of landlording: small claims courts see more deposit fights than almost any other landlord-tenant issue, and the landlords who lose usually lose on documentation, not on the law. The rules are actually fairly consistent across states — the differences are in the deadlines and the penalties, which are covered in the security deposit return deadlines by state guide. This page is about the other half: what you can deduct, and what counts as damage versus the ordinary wear of living in a place.

The four things you can usually deduct

In most states, a security deposit may be applied to four kinds of amounts, and only those four:

What you can't deduct is just as important: pre-existing damage that was there at move-in, the cost of bringing the unit up to a better standard than it was in, and anything your state specifically excludes. A few states also ban the phrase "non-refundable deposit" outright — a deposit by any other name is still a deposit, and it still has to be returned or accounted for.

Normal wear and tear: the line that decides most disputes

Normal wear and tear is the deterioration that happens from ordinary, careful living — no negligence, no accidents, no abuse. Damage is everything else. The distinction sounds vague until you put examples next to each other:

ItemNormal wear (not deductible)Damage (deductible)
PaintFaded or lightly scuffed after 3+ yearsLarge holes, unauthorized repaint in another color, smoke stains
CarpetFlattened traffic paths, light fadingPet urine stains, burns, large tears, red wine stains
WallsA few small nail holes from hanging picturesDoor-sized holes, dozens of anchor holes, crayon or marker
AppliancesWorn finish, a drip pan darkened by useBroken door, missing racks, damage from misuse
FixturesLoose grout, a slow faucet drip from ageCracked mirror, broken window, shattered light cover

Age matters, and judges know it. A carpet has a useful life of roughly 8–10 years; interior paint roughly 3–5. You can't charge a tenant the full replacement cost of something that was already most of the way through its life — you can charge, at most, its remaining value. That rule alone decides a lot of cases.

Charge only the remaining value, not the replacement cost. Say the carpet cost $1,200 new with an 8-year life — $150 of value per year. A tenant who lived there six years used $900 of it, leaving $300. If the carpet is ruined beyond cleaning, the most you can fairly deduct is $300, not $1,200. A 6-year-old carpet is not a new carpet, and a judge will do exactly this arithmetic.

Documentation that wins disputes

Every deduction you claim needs a paper trail, and the trail has to start at move-in, not move-out. The four pieces that matter:

What you can't do with a deposit

If the damage costs more than the deposit

It happens — a tenant leaves $2,400 of damage against a $1,500 deposit. The deposit covers the first $1,500; the rest is a debt you can pursue. Send the itemized statement showing the full cost, the deposit applied, and the balance owed, with the receipts attached. If the tenant doesn't pay, small claims court is built for exactly this: no lawyer needed, filing fees are low, and your move-in/move-out photos plus invoices are usually enough. Keep the same records either way — the statement you send is also the evidence you file.

The move-out routine

  1. Inspect within a few days of move-out, with the tenant present if possible, and photograph everything before any cleaning or repair starts.
  2. Get real quotes for each repair — don't guess. If a contractor can't come for a week, get the written estimate now and the paid invoice later.
  3. Write the itemized statement the day the work is done: each deduction, the reason, the amount, the receipt attached.
  4. Return the remainder by your state's deadline with the statement, by a method you can prove — certified mail or a trackable delivery, not a hand-off with no receipt.

Track it in one spreadsheet

The Rental Property Tracker logs rent and expenses per property, maps every expense to its Schedule E line, and prints a CPA-ready year-end summary. Start with the free one-sheet rent ledger, or get the full tracker.

Get the Tracker — $29 Free Rent Ledger (Excel)

One-time price · Excel & Google Sheets · Bundle with Airbnb module available for $49.

FAQ

Can I charge the tenant for cleaning the unit after they leave?

Yes, if the unit was left dirtier than move-in condition and your lease requires the tenant to return it clean. Routine turnover cleaning — the standard clean you'd do between any two tenants — is generally your cost, not a deposit deduction. The difference is the condition: ordinary dust and use is turnover; grease, grime and trash left behind is a deduction.

Can I keep the deposit for unpaid rent?

Yes — unpaid rent is the most clearly allowed deduction in every state. Apply the deposit to the rent owed, list it on the itemized statement, and return whatever is left. If the rent owed is more than the deposit, the balance is still owed and you can pursue it.

The lease says the deposit is non-refundable. Does that hold up?

Usually not. Most states treat any money held as security for the lease as a deposit regardless of the label, and require it to be returned or itemized. A few states allow a separate, clearly labeled non-refundable fee — but it has to be a fee, not a deposit by another name. Check your state's statute before relying on the label.

What if the tenant disputes my deductions?

Your itemized statement and receipts are your defense, and the move-in/move-out photos are what usually settle it. If the tenant sues in small claims court, bring the signed move-in checklist, both sets of photos, and every invoice. Landlords who can show before-and-after photos and actual paid receipts win these far more often than landlords who show estimates and memory.