It is one of the most common landlord situations and one of the least understood: your daughter needs a place, your brother is between jobs, your parents want to downsize into your spare unit, and you charge them well below what a stranger would pay. The rent is real income and you report it. The expenses are real expenses — but the IRS will not let you deduct them the way a normal rental does. The reason is the fair rental price rule: when you rent to a related person for less than fair rental value, the IRS treats the days they live there as days you used the property yourself.
This is not a rule about intent. You do not need to be trying to dodge tax, and the IRS does not need to prove a motive. The test is mechanical: who lives there, what they pay, and what the market would pay. Get the rent right and the property is a rental like any other. Get it wrong and the year's loss — which is usually the whole point of owning a rental for tax purposes — disappears.
The fair rental price test
Fair rental price is what a stranger would pay for the same property in the same condition, in the same neighborhood, on the same terms. It is not your mortgage payment, not what the tenant can afford, and not the number you used last year. The practical way to establish it is three comparable listings for similar units nearby, saved with dates and screenshots. If comparable two-bedrooms rent for $1,700 to $1,900 and you charge your son $1,800, you are at market. If you charge him $1,000, you are not — and the consequences follow automatically.
"Related person" is broader than most people expect: your spouse, children, grandchildren, parents, grandparents, brothers, sisters, and their spouses. It also includes a partner in a partnership you control and certain related entities. A friend is not a related person for this rule — renting cheap to a friend has its own problems (the IRS can still argue the rent is not arm's length), but the personal-use reclassification in this article is about family.
What happens when rent is below market
When a related person lives in the property for less than fair rental price, every day they are there counts as a personal-use day. That has three consequences, and they stack:
| Consequence | What it means in practice |
|---|---|
| Deductions capped at gross rental income | You can deduct expenses only up to the rent collected. No rental loss, ever. |
| Ordering rule applies | Expenses are deducted in a fixed order — mortgage interest and taxes first, then operating expenses, then depreciation last — so depreciation is usually the part that gets cut off. |
| Personal-use day count grows | The days count toward the 14-day / 10% personal-use threshold, which can change how the whole property is classified. |
The ordering matters because it decides which deductions survive. Interest and property tax are deducted first and are almost always fully usable; utilities, insurance, and repairs come next; depreciation comes last and is usually the deduction that gets zeroed out. The excess expenses are not carried forward and not banked for a later year — they are simply lost. And because there is no loss, there is nothing to shelter other income with: the $25,000 passive-loss allowance never comes into play, because there is no allowable loss to use. The passive-loss guide explains what a normal rental loss can do — a below-market family rental cannot do any of it.
The one thing to remember: below-market rent to family turns a rental into a personal-use property for tax purposes. You still report the rent as income, but your deductions stop at the rent collected and the loss disappears. If the discount is the point, the tax cost is the price of the discount — budget for it, or charge market rent and help in another way.
The numbers: $1,000 rent on a $1,800 apartment
Your daughter rents your two-bedroom for $1,000 a month. Comparable units rent for $1,800. Your annual expenses on the property are $15,000: mortgage interest $6,000, property tax $2,400, insurance $1,200, repairs $1,400, and depreciation $4,000. Here is the year:
| At market rent ($1,800/mo) | At family rent ($1,000/mo) | |
|---|---|---|
| Gross rent collected | $21,600 | $12,000 |
| Total expenses | $15,000 | $15,000 |
| Deductible expenses | $15,000 | $12,000 (capped) |
| Reported rental result | $6,600 profit | $0 (no loss allowed) |
| Lost deductions | $0 | $3,000 gone |
The $3,000 of lost deductions is the quiet part of the bill. At a 22% bracket it is about $660 of tax that a market-rent landlord would not pay — on top of the $9,600 of rent you gave up by charging $1,000 instead of $1,800. The total cost of the discount is roughly $10,260 a year. That does not make it wrong: helping family is a legitimate reason to charge less. It makes it a decision that should be made with the full price visible.
The exception: market rent to a family member who lives there
There is an important exception, and it is the one that saves most family rentals. If you rent to a related person at fair rental value, and they use the property as their principal residence, the days are treated as rental days, not personal-use days — even though the tenant is family. Your daughter paying $1,800 for the $1,800 apartment is a normal rental for tax purposes: full deductions, a loss if the numbers produce one, and Schedule E treatment like any other tenant. The family relationship alone does not trigger the rule; the discount does.
The same logic applies to a partial discount that is still within the market range. If comparable units run $1,700 to $1,900 and you charge $1,750, you are at market even though you could have charged $1,900. The IRS does not require the highest possible rent — it requires a fair one. Document the range, pick a defensible number inside it, and the property stays a rental.
How to document it
Family rentals fail on documentation more than on the rent itself. Use a written lease with the same terms you would give a stranger — same deposit, same late fee, same notice language. Collect the rent the same way, into the same separate rental account, on the same day each month. Save three comparable listings at the time the lease is signed, with the rent, the address, and the date. If the tenant is a family member paying market rent, keep a note that the unit is their principal residence. The deductions checklist and the Schedule E walkthrough both assume a normal rental — they only apply in full when the rent passes this test. If you are charging below market, file the return as a personal-use property and do not claim the loss, no matter how tempting the deduction looks.
Track it in one spreadsheet
The Rental Property Tracker logs rent and expenses per property, maps every expense to its Schedule E line, and prints a CPA-ready year-end summary. Start with the free one-sheet rent ledger, or get the full tracker.
Get the Tracker — $29 Free Rent Ledger (Excel)
One-time price · Excel & Google Sheets · Bundle with Airbnb module available for $49.
FAQ
Can I charge my son less rent and make up the difference with a gift?
Yes — charging market rent and separately gifting money is cleaner than discounting the rent. The rent stays at fair value, the property stays a rental for tax purposes, and the gift is a separate transaction (subject to the annual gift-tax exclusion, $19,000 per recipient for 2026). Do not net the two together on the books; keep the rent and the gift as separate transfers.
Does this rule apply if I rent cheap to a friend?
Not in the same mechanical way — a friend is not a related person under this rule, so the days are not automatically personal-use days. But the IRS can still challenge whether the arrangement is a genuine rental at arm's length, and expenses beyond the rent collected are harder to defend. A written lease and market-rate documentation protect you in either case.
What if my family member only lives there part of the year?
The days they live there below market count as personal-use days; days rented to an unrelated tenant at market rate count as rental days. The property's classification for the year depends on the totals — which is why the 14-day / 10% personal-use threshold matters — and the deduction cap applies to the expenses attributable to the personal-use portion. Keep a day-by-day log when a property is mixed-use.
Can I deduct the mortgage interest anyway, on Schedule A?
Interest and property tax that exceed the rental-income cap are generally treated as personal expenses, and mortgage interest on a property that is not your principal residence or a qualified second home is not deductible on Schedule A. In practice, the excess is usually lost — another reason to decide the rent level deliberately rather than discovering the cap in April.