Suppose you bought a rental for $180,000, depreciated it for years, and now it is worth $320,000. Sell it outright and you owe tax on the gain plus depreciation recapture — a bill that can easily reach $30,000–$40,000 depending on your bracket and how much depreciation you claimed. Or you can do a Section 1031 like-kind exchange: sell the property, have a qualified intermediary hold the proceeds, and buy another rental property of equal or greater value. The tax is not forgiven — it is deferred, carried into the new property's basis — but the money that would have gone to the IRS stays in your portfolio and keeps earning. For a landlord trading up from a single-family rental to a duplex, that is often the single biggest tax decision of the year.
There is a catch, and it is the whole subject of this page: the exchange is governed by two deadlines that do not bend. You have 45 calendar days from the sale to identify the replacement property, and 180 calendar days to close on it. Weekends, holidays and the fact that your lender is slow all count. This page explains the rules, the worked math, and the five traps that kill exchanges for small landlords.
How an exchange actually works
A 1031 exchange is almost never a direct swap of one deed for another. In practice it is a delayed exchange with three parties: you, the buyer of your old property, and a qualified intermediary (QI) — a neutral company that holds the sale proceeds so you never touch the money. If the proceeds hit your bank account, even for a day, the exchange fails and the sale is taxable. The sequence is fixed:
- Before closing on the sale, you sign an exchange agreement with a QI. This must happen before the sale closes — you cannot decide to do an exchange after the money is in hand.
- Day 0: the sale closes. The proceeds go to the QI, not to you. The 45-day and 180-day clocks start the day after closing (the regulations count the day after the transfer as day 1).
- By day 45, you deliver a written identification of the replacement property to the QI (and usually to the other parties). The identification must describe the property unambiguously — address and legal description.
- By day 180, you close on the replacement property, with the QI paying the seller directly from the exchange funds. The 180 days run from the sale of the old property, not from the identification — and if your tax return for the sale year is due sooner, the exchange must close before that due date unless you file an extension.
The QI typically charges $800–$1,500 for a straightforward delayed exchange. That fee is paid from the exchange funds and is cheap compared with the tax at stake — but the QI must be a genuine third party. Your CPA, your attorney, your real estate agent and your family members are all disqualified from serving as your QI.
The identification rules: the 3-property rule and the 200% rule
By day 45 you must identify the replacement property, and the IRS gives you three ways to do it:
- The 3-property rule: identify up to three properties of any value, and close on one or more of them. This is the rule almost every small landlord uses.
- The 200% rule: identify any number of properties, as long as their combined fair market value is no more than 200% of the value of the property you sold.
- The 95% exception: identify any number of properties of any value, but then you must actually acquire 95% of their combined value — a rule that is almost never worth using.
The practical advice: identify three properties. Your first choice may fall through — a bad inspection, a financing problem — and if you identified only one property and it dies on day 60, your exchange dies with it. Identifying three gives you two backups, and you are allowed to buy any of the three. What you cannot do is identify a property on day 46. The identification deadline has no extensions, and the IRS has no hardship exception for it.
| Deadline | Counts from | What must happen |
|---|---|---|
| Day 45 | Day after the sale closes | Written identification of replacement property delivered to the QI |
| Day 180 | Day after the sale closes | Closing on the replacement property (or your tax return due date, if earlier) |
| — | — | Both deadlines are calendar days; weekends and holidays count |
Worked timeline: your sale closes on Monday, March 2. Day 45 is Thursday, April 16. Day 180 is Saturday, August 29 — and if August 29 is a Saturday, you must close by Friday, August 28, because the deadline does not roll to Monday. Always work backward from the calendar, not from business days.
The math: what is deferred, and what is not
Take the example from the introduction: you bought for $180,000, claimed $60,000 of depreciation over the years, so your adjusted basis is $120,000. You sell for $320,000 and pay $20,000 in selling costs, giving you a realized gain of $180,000. In an ordinary sale, the $60,000 of depreciation is recaptured at up to 25% ($15,000 of tax) and the remaining $120,000 of gain is taxed at the capital gains rate — say 15%, or $18,000. Total tax: about $33,000, before state tax.
In a successful exchange, that $33,000 is deferred: you buy a replacement property for at least $320,000, your $120,000 basis carries over (adjusted for the exchange), and the $60,000 of depreciation recapture is deferred too — it will be recaptured when you eventually sell the replacement property in a taxable sale. The deferral is not a loophole you have to apologize for; it is the statute working exactly as written, and the price of it is the discipline of the deadlines and the basis carryover.
Two things are not deferred. First, boot: any cash or other non-like-kind property you take out of the exchange is taxed. If you sell for $320,000, buy a $300,000 replacement and pocket the $20,000 difference, that $20,000 is boot and is taxable. The safe rule is to buy equal or greater value and replace all the debt — trading down in price or reducing your mortgage both create boot. Second, suspended passive losses: a 1031 exchange is not a fully taxable disposition, so it does not release suspended losses. If you have losses banked under the passive loss rules, they stay suspended until a taxable sale or a year with passive income.
The one thing to remember: the deadlines are calendar days, and day 45 is the one that kills most exchanges. The 180-day closing deadline feels like the hard one, but closings can be pushed and lenders can be hurried. The 45-day identification deadline cannot be extended for any reason — not a failed inspection, not a slow lender, not a holiday. Start looking for the replacement property before you list the old one, and have your second and third choices picked before day 45 arrives.
Five traps that kill exchanges for small landlords
1. Touching the money. The proceeds must go to the QI. A wire to your account, even by mistake, ends the exchange. Tell your closing agent in writing, before closing, that this is a 1031 and the funds go to the intermediary.
2. A personal-use property. Both properties must be held for productive use in a trade or business or for investment. Your primary residence does not qualify, and a vacation home you use personally most of the year does not either. The IRS safe harbor for a second home is strict: rent it at fair market value for at least 14 days a year and keep your personal use to 14 days or 10% of the rental days, whichever is greater.
3. Trading down. Buying a cheaper replacement, taking cash out, or dropping your mortgage balance all create taxable boot. Run the numbers with your CPA before you agree on a price — the exchange only defers tax on the value you actually reinvest.
4. Related parties. Exchanging with a family member is allowed, but both sides must hold the properties for at least two years afterward, and the IRS watches these transactions closely. Do not use a related-party exchange to move a property into the family at a stepped-up value.
5. Forgetting the depreciation clock. The replacement property inherits the old basis, which means its depreciation is based on the carried-over basis, not the price you paid. A $320,000 replacement with a $120,000 carried basis depreciates far more slowly than a $320,000 purchase would — the depreciation guide explains why basis matters more than price. Run the depreciation schedule on the replacement before you commit, so the smaller annual deduction is a surprise to no one.
Track it in one spreadsheet
The Rental Property Tracker logs rent and expenses per property, maps every expense to its Schedule E line, and prints a CPA-ready year-end summary. Start with the free one-sheet rent ledger, or get the full tracker.
Get the Tracker — $29 Free Rent Ledger (Excel)
One-time price · Excel & Google Sheets · Bundle with Airbnb module available for $49.
FAQ
Can I do a 1031 exchange into a property in another state?
Yes. Like-kind means real property for real property — a single-family rental in Texas can be exchanged for a duplex in Ohio. The properties do not need to be the same type, the same size or in the same state, as long as both are held for investment or business use.
Does a 1031 exchange work for a property I flipped?
No. Property held primarily for sale — a flip — is inventory, not investment property, and it does not qualify. The property must have been held for rental or investment use. A property you rented for a year or two and then sold usually qualifies; one you bought, renovated and listed within months usually does not.
What happens if I miss the 45-day deadline?
The exchange fails and the sale is taxed as an ordinary sale in the year it closed — gain, depreciation recapture and all. There is no extension and no reasonable-cause relief for the identification deadline. The one exception is a federally declared disaster that postpones deadlines, which the IRS announces case by case.
Can I exchange into a property I already own?
No. The replacement property must be acquired as part of the exchange, from an unrelated seller, with exchange funds. You cannot exchange into a property you already own, and you cannot use exchange funds to pay off a mortgage on property you already hold.